COMPARISON OF EMPLOYERS’ AND STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS REGARDING COMMUNICATION SKILLS

Dragana Bozic Lenard, Ljiljana Pintarić

DOI Number
10.22190/JTESAP1801063B
First page
063
Last page
082

Abstract


Internationalization and fierce competitiveness have become the benchmarks of the modern labor market. Ever increasing demands have widened the roles of engineers in such a way that hard skills are insufficient and have to be complemented with transferable generic skills. This research aimed to compare the students’ and employers’ perceptions on demanded communication skills. 99 students studying at the Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Computer Science and Information Technology Osijek and 61 employers closely cooperating with the Faculty participated in the anonymous online survey. The results were processed with SPSS where the chi-square test for independence was performed. The results point to great discrepancies between the employers’ demands and the students’ perceptions on prospective employers’ demands. The employers demand well-rounded listeners and speakers who will pay a lot of attention to both verbal and non-verbal communication. They aim to create a productive working atmosphere expecting that their employees professionally collaborate, which the students are not fully aware of. Both the students and employers perceive conforming to business writing etiquette and skilful presenting as extremely important for achieving business success. The results point to the necessity of revising curricula and implement communication skills to meet the needs of the labor market.

Keywords

employers, students, perceptions, communication skills, comparison

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abas, Maripaz and Ombra, Imam, A., “Graduates’ Competence on Employability Skills and Job Performance,” International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education 5(2) (2016): 119-125.

Adams, Karen and Missingham, Dorthy, “Contributions to Student Learning: An overview of Engineering Communication courses in Mechanical Engineering education,” (School of Mechanical Engineering, University of Adelaide, 2006).

Adler, Ronald, Lawrence Rosenfeld and Russel Proctor, Interplay: the process of interpersonal communicating (Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt, 2001).

Ahmad, Esa, Selamat, Asri, Suhaili, Padil and Jamaludin, Jaslina, “Applications of Soft Skills in Engineering Programme at Polytechnic Malaysia,” Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 140, (2014): 115 – 120.

American Management Association (AMA), “Executives say the 21st century requires more skilled workers,” 2010. doi. http://www.p21.org/documents/CriticalSkillsSurveyExecutiveSummary.pdf.

Andrews, Jane and Higson, Helen, “Graduate Employability, 'Soft Skills' Versus 'Hard' Knowledge: A European Study,” Higher Education in Europe 33(4) (2008): 411-422.

Australian Association of Graduate Employers (AAGE), AAGE Employer Survey: Survey Report (Melbourne: High Flyers Research, 2012).

Australian Association of Graduate Employers (AAGE), AAGE Employer Survey: Survey Report (Melbourne: High Flyers Research, 2014).

Bacon, Donald and Anderson, Elizabeth Scott, “Assessing and enhancing the basic writing skills of marketing students,” Business and Professional Communication Quarterly 67(4) (2004): 443-454.

Barrett, Deborah, “Achieving results in MBA communication,” Business and Professional Communication Quarterly 65(3) (2002): 93-98.

Bath, Debra, Smith, Calvin, Stein, Sarah and Swann, Richard, “Beyond mapping and embedding graduate attributes: bringing together quality assurance and action learning to create a validated and living curriculum,” Higher Education Research and Development 23(3) (2004): 313–328.

Bean, Virginia L. and Watanabe, Judith E, “An Investigation into the Importance of Communication Skills.” Journal of Applied Business Research 4(4) (2011): 1-6.

Beebe, Steven and Beebe, Susan, Public speaking: An audience-centered approach (New York: Pearson, 2006).

Bennett, Roger, “Employers' demands for personal transferable skills in graduates: A content analysis of 1000 job advertisements and an associated empirical study,” Journal of Vocational Education and Training 54(4) (2002): 457-476.

Blahova, Maria, “Specific role of nonverbal communication in business.” European Scientific Journal 11(10) (2015): 9-19.

Bonaccio, Silvia, O’Reilly, Jane, O’Sullivan, Sharon L. and Chiocchio, François, “Nonverbal Behavior and Communication in the Workplace: A Review and an Agenda for Research.” Journal of Management 42(5) (2016): 1044-1074.

Bridgstock, Ruth, “The graduate attributes we’ve overlooked: Enhancing graduate employability through career management skills,” Higher Education Research & Development 28(1) (2009): 31-44.

Brodowsky, Glen and Anderson, Beverlee, “Student perceptions of communication skills: Writing, presentations, and public speaking,” Journal of the Academy of Business Education 4 (2003): 13-22.

Burgoon, Judee, Laura Guerrero and Kory Floyd, Nonverbal Communication (London: Routledge, 2016).

Cambridge report, English at Work: global analysis of language skills in the workplace (Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2016). doi: http://cambridgeenglish.org/images/english-at-work-full-report.pdf

Carnevale, Anthony and Smith, Nicole, “Workplace basics: the skills employees need and employers want,” Human Resource Development International 16(5) (2013): 491-501.

Certo, Samuel, Modern management: Diversity, quality, ethics and the global environment (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 2000).

Clarke, Marilyn, “Understanding and managing employability in changing career contexts,” Journal of European Industrial Training 32(4) (2008): 258-284.

Clement, Aloy and Tamil Murugavel, “English for Employability: A Case Study of the English Language Training Need Analysis for Engineering Students in India,” English Language Teaching 8(2) (2015): 116-125.

Cline, Stephanie, “Soft skills make the difference in the workplace,” The Colorado Springs Business 1 (2005), article 1.

Crosling, Glenda and Ward, Ian, “Oral communication: The workplace needs and uses of business graduate employees.” English for Specific Purposes 21 (1) (2002): 41-57.

Dannels, Deanna, “Taking the pulse of communication across the curriculum: A view from the trenches,” Journal of the Association for Communication Administration 30 (2001): 50-70.

Dannels, Deanna, Anson, Chris M., Bullard, Lisa and Peretti, Steven, “Challenges in Learning Communication Skills in Chemical Engineering,” Communication Education 52(1) (2003): 50-56.

Darling, Ann L. and Dannels, Deanna, “Practicing Engineers Talk about the Importance of Talk: A Report on the Role of Oral Communication in the Workplace,” Communication Education 52(1) (2003): 1-16.

Delaney, Deborah Anne, Fletcher, Marty, Cameron, Craig and Bodle, Kerry, “Online self and peer assessment of team work in accounting education,” Accounting Research Journal 26(3) (2013): 222-238.

Du-Babcock, Bertha, “Teaching business communication: Past, present, and future.” International Journal of Business Communication 43(3) (2006): 253-264.

Dunbar, Norah, Catherine Brooks and Tara Kubicka-Miller, “Oral Communication Skills in Higher Education: Using a Performance-Based Evaluation Rubric to Assess Communication Skills.” Innovative Higher Education 31 (2) (2006): 115-128.

Edmondston, Joanne, Dawson, Vaille and Schibeci, Renato, “Are students prepared to communicate? A case study of an Australian degree course in biotechnology,” International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education 8(6) (2010): 1091-1108.

Ellis, Kathleen, Shockley-Zalabak, Pamela and Hackman, Michael, “Communication laboratories: Genesis, assessment, challenges,” Journal of the Association for Communication 29 (2000): 155-162.

Fay, Martha J. and Kline, Susan L., “The influence of informal communication on organizational identification and commitment in the context of high-intensity telecommuting.” Southern Communication Journal 77(1) (2012): 61-76.

Forbes, How Much Coworker Socializing Is Good For Your Career? 2013. doi: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jacquelynsmith/2013/09/24/how-much-coworker-socializing-is-good-for-your-career/#4a2f268751a0

Fraleigh, Douglas and Tuman, Joseph, Speak up! An illustrated guide to public speaking (New York: Bedford/St. Martins, 2009).

Froman, Larry, “Positive psychology in the workplace,” Journal of Adult Development 17(2) (2010): 59-69.

Gamauf, Mike, “The importance of good tech talk,” Business & Commercial Aviation 95(6) (2004): 66-69.

Glikson, Ella, Cheshin, Arik and van Kleef, Gerben A. “The Dark Side of a Smiley Effects of Smiling Emoticons on Virtual First Impressions,” Social Psychology and Personality Science July 2017. doi: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1948550617720269#articleCitationDownloadContainer

Grapsas, Anne and Vojislav Ilić, “Behaviour, Ethics and Communication at the Workplace: A Subject For Al!.” Paper presented in International Conference on Engineering Education, Oslo, Norway, 2001.

Gray, Elizabeth, “Specific oral communication skills desired in new accountancy graduates.” Business and Professional Communication Quarterly 73 (1) (2010): 40-67.

Gray, Elizabeth, Emerson, Lisa and Mackay, Bruce, “Meeting the Demands of the Workplace: Science Students and Written Skills,” Journal of Science Education and Technology 14(4) (2005): 425-435.

Halil Gerek, Ibrahim and Efe Efeoglu, Ibrahim, “What qualifications and skills are important for civil engineers? A job advertisement analysis,” Proceedings of Management, Knowledge and Learning Joint International Conference, Italy: Bari, 2015: 689-695.

Hansen, Randall S., “Benefits and problems with students teams: Suggestions for improving team projects,” Journal of Education for Business 82(1) (2006): 11-19.

Hartman, Jackie L. and McCambridge, Jim, “Optimizing millennials’ communication styles,” Business Communication Quarterly 74 (1) (2011): 22-44.

Haslam, Jonathan, “Learning the lesson - Speaking up for communication as an academic discipline too important to be sidelined,” Journal of Communication Management 7(1) (2003): 14-20.

Haworth, Ian S. and Garrill, Ashley, “Assessment of verbal communication in science education,” Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education 31(1) (2003): 24-27.

Helsel, Christine R. and Hogg, Mary C., “Assessing communication proficiency in higher education: Speaking labs offer possibilities,” International Journal of Listening, 20 (2006): 29-54.

Hinchliffe, Geoffrey William and Jolly, Adrienne, “Graduate identity and employability,” British Educational Research Journal 37(4) (2011): 563–584.

Hunter, James, Vickery, Jo and Smyth, Robyn, “Enhancing learning outcomes through group work in an internationalised undergraduate business education context,” Journal of Management and Organization 16(5) (2010): 700-714.

Jackling, Beverley, Natoli, Riccardo, Siddique, Salina and Sciulli, Nick, “Student attitudes to blogs: a case study of reflective and collaborative learning,” Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 40(4) (2015): 542-556.

Jackson, Denise, Sibson, Ruth and Riebe, Linda, “Undergraduate perceptions of the development of team-working skills,” Education + Training 56(1) (2014): 7-20

Jaderstrom, Susan and Schoenrock, Ramona, “Teaching the NBEA communication standards.” Business Education Forum 62 (4) (2008): 25-29.

Jungert, Tomas, “The meaning of support from co-workers and managers in teams when working,” (Linköping: Linköping University, 2012).

Kassim, Hafizoah and Fatimah Ali, “English communicative events and skills needed at the workplace: Feedback from the industry,” English for Specific Purposes 29 (3) (2010): 168-182.

Kirby, Debra and Romine, Jeff, “Develop oral presentation skills through accounting curriculum design and course-embedded assessment,” Journal of Education for Business 85(3) (2009): 172-179.

Longnecker, Nancy, “Sharing science with better science communication,” Issues 87 (2009): 37-40.

Lowden, Kevin, Stuart Hall, Dely Elliot and Lewin, Jon, “Employers’ perceptions of the employability skills on new graduates,” Edge Foundation: University of Glasgow SCRE Centre and Edge Foundation, 2011.

Matturro, Gerardo, “Soft Skills in Software Engineering: A Study of its Demand by Software Companies in Uruguay,” Proceedings of Cooperative and Human Aspects of Software Engineering, Italy: Florence, 2013: 133-136.

McMurray, Stephen, Dutton, Matthew, McQuaid, Ronald and Richard, Alec, “Employer demands from business graduates,” Education + Training 58(1) (2016): 112-132.

Mehrabian, Albert, “Silent Messages – A Wealth of Information About Nonverbal Communication (Body Language).” Personality & Emotion Tests & Software: Psychological Books & Articles of Popular Interest, 2009.

Morreale, Sherwyn, Pamela Shockley-Zalabak and Penny Whitney, “The Center for Excellence in Oral Communication: Integrating Communication Across the Curriculum.” Communication Education 42 (1) (2009): 10-21.

Nair, Chenicheri Sid, Patil, Arun and Mertova, Patricie, “Re-engineering graduate skills – a case study,” European Journal of Engineering Education 34(2) (2009): 131-139.

National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE), “NACE research report: Job outlook 2010,” 2010. doi: http://www.naceweb.org.

National Commission on Writing, Writing: A ticket to work…or a ticket out (College Entrance Examination Board, 2004). doi: http://www.collegeboard.com/prod_downloads/writingcom/writing-ticket-to-work.pdf

Neves, Pedro and Eisenberger, Robert, “Management communication and employee performance: the contribution of perceived organizational support,” Human Performance 25(5) (2012): 452-464.

North, Alexa and Worth, William, “Trends in selected entry-level technology, interpersonal, and basic communication SCANS skills: 1992-2002,” Journal of Employment Counselling 41(2) (2004): 60-70.

Patil, Arun, “The global engineering criteria for the development of a global engineering profession,” World Transaction on Engineering Education 4(1) (2005): 49–52.

Patoko, Ngueviuta and Yazdanifard, Rashad, “The Impact of Using Many Jargon Words, while Communicating with the Organization Employees,” American Journal of Industrial and Business Management 4 (2014): 567-572.

Pfaff, Elizabeth and Huddleston, Patrizia, “Does it matter if I hate teamwork? What impacts student attitudes toward teamwork,” Journal of Marketing Education 25(1) (2003): 37-45.

Pittenger, Khushwant, Miller, Mary and Mott, Joshua, “Using Real‐world Standards to Enhance Students' Presentation Skills,” Business and Professional Communication Quarterly 67(3) (2004): 327-336.

Radcliffe, David, “Innovation as a meta attribute for graduate engineers,” International Journal of Engineering Education 21(2) (2005): 194–199.

Raftopoulos, Melandi, Van der Westhuizen, Sanet and Visser, Delene, “Work-readiness skills in the fastest sector,” SA Journal of Human Resource Management 7(1) (2009): 119–126.

Rajprasit, Krich, Panadda Pratoomrat, Tuntiga Wang, Supanit Kulsiri and Saengchan Hemchua, “Use of the English language prior to and during employment: experiences and needs of Thai novice engineers.” Global Journal of Engineering Education 16(1) (2014): 27-33.

Raybould, Joanne and Sheedy, Victoria, “Are graduates equipped with the right skills in the employability stakes?” Industrial and Commercial Training 37(5) (2005): 259–263.

Raziq, Abdul and Maulabakhsh, Raheela, “Impact of Working Environment on Job Satisfaction,” Procedia Economics and Finance 23 (2015): 717 – 725.

Riemer, Marc, “English and Communication Skills for the Global Engineer.” Global Journal of Engineering Education 6 (1) (2002): 91-100.

Riemer, Marc, “Communication Skills for the 21st Century Engineer,” Global Journal of Engineering Education 11(1) (2007): 89-100.

Riemer, Marc and Jansen, Detlev, “Non-verbal intercultural communication awareness for the modern engineer,” World Transactions on Engineering and Technology Education 2(3) (2003): 373-378.

Roebuck, Deborah Britt, Improving business communication skills (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 2001).

Sageev, Pneena and Carol Romanowski, “A message from recent engineering graduates in the marketplace: Results of a survey on technical communication skills.” Journal of Engineering Education 90 (4) (2001): 685-697.

Schnell, Linda Marie, “Work In Progress: Impacting Global Engineering Education For New College Graduates.” Proceedings of the 36th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference (2006): 18-19.

Seetha, Shikha, “Communication skills for engineers in global arena.” International Journal on Arts, Management and Humanities 1 (1) (2012): 1-6.

Seibu, Mary Jacob, Huui, Lee Miin and Sueh Ing Su, “Employer satisfaction with graduate skills: a case study from Malaysian business enterprises,” Proceedings of International Conference on Business and Information, Singapore, 2006. doi: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/255580516

Sheth, Tarjani Dakshesh, “Communication Skill: A Prerequisite for Engineers,” International Journal on Studies in English Language and Literature 3(7) (2015): 51-54

Sias, Patrizia, Organizing relationships: Traditional and emerging perspectives on workplace relationships (Los Angeles: Sage, 2009).

Sjursen, Harold, “The new alliance between engineering and humanities educators,” Proceedings of 6th Baltic Region Seminar on Engineering Education, Szczecin, Poland, 2006: 35-39.

Skovholt, Karianne, Grønning, Anette and Kankaanranta, Anne, “The Communicative Functions of Emoticons in Workplace E-Mails: :-),” Journal of Computer-mediated Communication 19(4) (2014): 780-97.

Stevens, Betsy, “What communication skills do employers want? Silicon valley recruiters respond,” Journal of Employment Counselling 42(1) (2005): 2-9.

Swart, Johannes and Rothmann, Sebastiaan, “Authentic happiness of managers, and individual organizational outcomes,” South African Journal of Psychology 42(4) (2012): 495-508.

The United States-Mexico Cultural and Educational Foundation and Harrison Maldonado Associates, Inc., English Proficiency: What Employers Need for Their Spanish-Speaking Workforce (The Bulow Group, Inc., 2016). doi: https://www.doleta.gov/reports/pdf/English_Proficiency_Report.pdf

Trevelyan, James, “Reconstructing engineering from practice,” Engineering Studies 2(3) (2010): 175-195.

UKCES, Employee Demand for Skills: A Review of Evidence & Policy – Executive Summary (London: WM Enterprise and Employment Research Institute, Edinburgh Napier University, 2009).

Wellington, Paul, Thomas, Ian, Powell, Irene, and Clarke, Brian, “Authentic assessment applied to engineering and business undergraduate consulting teams,” International Journal of Engineering Education 18(2) (2002): 168–179.

Wilkinson, Sophie, “Industry’s wish list for academia,” Chemical Engineering News 80 (2002): 34-37.

Young, Mark and Murphy, William, “Integrating communications skills into the marketing curriculum: A case study.” Journal of Marketing Education 25(1) (2003): 57-70.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.22190/JTESAP1801063B

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2334-9182 (Print)
ISSN 2334-9212 (Online)